You are a case review team. A man has been found dead below Thornwick Head. Read the case file, work out who killed him, how and why, and build a charging file that will satisfy the Crown Prosecution Service.
Players: 1–6 (best with 3–5). Time: an evening: about 2½–3 hours for a team of four, longer with fewer players. You can stop and come back at any time.
Getting started
- Read DCI Hartley's briefing (Document 00). Everyone reads it first.
- Each player has a desk: a pile of documents to start on. You can open any document at any time.
- When you find something important, pass it to a teammate (or to everyone) with a note, and pin it to the findings board. Pin generously: at the end, your charging file can only cite passages that are on the board.
The three stages
| Stage | What arrives | How it opens |
|---|---|---|
| 1 — The scene | The first day's statements, reports and maps | At the start |
| 2 — Enquiries | Forensics, phone records, alibi checks, interviews | Your first case review to DCI Hartley is approved |
| 3 — Deep background | Warrants, the past, the last pieces | Your second case review is approved |
A case review is a short form your team agrees and submits together (a team vote). If Hartley isn't satisfied, he'll tell you why. Revise it and send it again.
Hints
Stuck? Anyone can request a case review on a question. The whole team votes; if the vote passes, Hartley replies with a hint. Hints come in three tiers: where to look, what to look for, and the answer. Using hints never stops you finishing; the reveal shows how many you used.
The ending
When your team is ready, draft a charging file: the suspect, the offence, the motive and up to five pieces of evidence (passages from the documents). Vote to send it. The CPS will reply with its decision. If it isn't authorised, you get one chance to revise. Then the truth is revealed.
Tips
- Statements are claims. Cameras, phone records, receipts and forensics are tests of those claims.
- Fix the time of the fatal blow, then ask where everyone was at that moment.
- Every suspect has something to hide. Not everyone who lies is a killer.
- Keep a shared timeline of Friday 7 June. Most contradictions show up there.